Car Lifts: Comparing Scissor Lifts vs. 2 Post Car Lifts

As a car enthusiast or professional mechanic, having the right equipment in your workshop or garage is essential. Two of the most popular types of car lifts are scissor lifts and 2 post car lifts.

When you’re frequently working on the underbelly of cars, you can’t rely on temporary solutions like air hydraulic jacks.

You need the vehicle to be held at a comfortable working height for sustained periods of time, making a car hoist a worthy and back-saving investment.

In this guide, we’ll have a look at the features, benefits, and considerations of each, helping you make an informed decision for your automotive needs.

Introduction to Car Lifts

Car lifts are indispensable tools that elevate vehicles, providing easy access for maintenance, repairs, and modifications. They come in various designs, each with its unique advantages and applications. Whether you’re a hobbyist working on your beloved project car or a professional mechanic servicing multiple vehicles daily, choosing the right car lift can significantly impact your productivity and safety.

Understanding the Different Types of Car Lifts

There are three main types of automotive lifts: surface-mounted lifts, which are installed on the ground and include scissor lifts, 2 post lifts, and 4 post lifts; in-ground lifts, which are installed below ground level for a flush surface and include parallelogram lifts and short-rise lifts; and mobile lifts, designed for portability and temporary use in workshops or garages where permanent installation is not feasible.

Scissor Lifts: Features and Benefits

What Is A Scissor Lift?

A scissor lift is a type of lifting equipment that utilises a scissor mechanism to raise and lower heavy loads. It consists of a platform, also known as a table, which is supported by a series of crisscrossed metal arms that expand and contract like a scissor when the platform is raised or lowered.

Scissor lifts are also known as alignment lifts or mid-rise lifts, are a popular choice for both professional and home mechanics.

Advantages of Scissor Lifts

Scissor lifts offer a low profile, making them suitable for vehicles with low clearance or garages with limited ceiling height. Their open design provides excellent access to the vehicle’s undercarriage, facilitating repairs and maintenance tasks.

Scissor lifts are versatile, accommodating various vehicle types and sizes, from compact cars to light-duty trucks and vans. Additionally, they are easy to install as many are surface-mounted, requiring minimal modifications to the existing floor or infrastructure.

Potential Drawbacks of Scissor Lifts

Scissor lifts, while adequate for most tasks, may have limited lifting height that could be insufficient for certain jobs or larger vehicles. Additionally, some users may perceive them as less stable compared to other lift types, especially when working on heavier vehicles or when raised to their maximum height.

2 Post Car Lifts: Features and Benefits

What Is a 2 Post Car Lift?

A 2 post car lift is a type of vehicle lift commonly used in automotive repair shops, service centers, and garages. As the name suggests, it consists of two vertical posts that support a platform, or carriage, that is used to lift a vehicle off the ground.

2 post car lifts are sometimes also referred to as clear-floor lifts or twin-post lifts.

Advantages of 2 Post Car Lifts

2 post lifts offer greater lifting heights compared to scissor lifts, providing better access to the undercarriage and enabling more clearance for taller vehicles or specific tasks. Their robust design, featuring sturdy columns and a crossbeam, ensures excellent stability and durability, even when lifting heavy vehicles. Positioned at the front and rear of the vehicle, 2 post lifts leave the floor area clear, facilitating easier movement and access around the lifted vehicle.

Potential Drawbacks of 2 Post Car Lifts

2 post lifts often require extensive installation, including reinforced concrete floors and specific ceiling height clearances. While they offer clear floor space, the posts can obstruct access to some areas of the vehicle’s undercarriage. They generally have a higher initial cost compared to scissor lifts, but they are known for their long-term durability and reliability.

Due to their design, 2 Post Car Lifts need at least 3 metres of vertical clearance. Luckily, they take up very little ground room. Scissor Lifts are the exact opposite of this, needing more floor space but less height.

Comparing Scissor Lifts and 2 Post Car Lifts

To help you make an informed decision, let’s compare some key aspects of scissor lifts and 2 post car lifts:

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Scissor Lifts and 2 Post Car Lifts

When choosing between 2 post lifts and scissor lifts, consider several factors: evaluate your workshop or garage space, including floor space, ceiling height, and layout to determine the most suitable lift type. Consider the types and sizes of vehicles you’ll be working on, as well as the required lifting heights for optimal access.

If you plan to use the lift frequently or for extended periods, a 2 post lift may be more suitable due to its durability and stability. Keep your budget in mind; while 2 post lifts generally have a higher initial cost, they may offer better long-term value and durability. Finally, if you prioritise ease of installation, a surface-mounted scissor lift may be the preferred choice.

Also worth considering is carrying capacity: depending on the model, the carrying capacity of a Scissor Lift can range between 2700-5500kg. Comparatively, 2 Post Car Lifts can shift up to 8000kg.

Safety and Maintenance Considerations for Car Lifts

Ensure your car lift is installed by a certified professional according to the manufacturer’s instructions and local regulations. Never exceed the maximum weight capacity specified by the lift manufacturer to avoid catastrophic failures and serious injuries.

Regularly inspect and maintain your car lift according to the manufacturer’s recommendations to ensure safe and reliable operation. To maximise their lifespan, both Scissor Lifts and 2 Post Car Lifts need regular services (every 3 months for the former and every 1 month for the latter). The repair costs will be fairly similar, depending on which part of the machine has been damaged.

Ensure all personnel operating the car lift are properly trained in safe operating procedures. Use appropriate safety equipment, such as vehicle restraints, axle stands, and personal protective equipment (PPE), when working with car lifts.

Lubricate moving parts and pivot points according to the manufacturer’s recommendations to reduce friction and wear. For hydraulic lifts, regularly check and maintain hydraulic fluid levels, hoses, and seals to prevent leaks and ensure proper operation.

Inspect and maintain electrical systems, including cables, switches, and control panels, for lifts with electrical components. Periodically conduct load testing to verify the lift’s capacity and ensure safe operation. Consider scheduling regular professional inspections by a certified technician to identify and address potential issues before they escalate.

Can You Store a Car on a 2 Post Lift?

Leaving a vehicle suspended on a lift for extended periods can accelerate wear and tear on the lift components, potentially leading to premature failure or maintenance issues.

Safety concerns increase with prolonged storage on a car lift, as there’s a higher risk of accidents or incidents like the lift settling or shifting, which could cause property damage or personal injury.

Regular maintenance and inspections become more challenging when a vehicle is stored on a lift, as access to certain components may be restricted.

If you must store a car on a 2 post lift for a short period, it’s crucial to follow the manufacturer’s guidelines and take appropriate safety precautions, such as using axle stands or additional support mechanisms.

Wrapping Up Scissor Lifts vs 2 Post Car Lifts

Choosing between a scissor lift and a 2 post car lift ultimately depends on your specific needs, workspace constraints, and personal preferences. Both lift types offer unique advantages and cater to different requirements.

Scissor lifts are an excellent choice for those seeking a versatile, low-profile, and easy-to-install solution.

2 post lifts provide increased lifting heights, stability, and durability, making them ideal for professional workshops or those working on larger vehicles.

Regardless of your choice, prioritising safety, proper installation, and regular maintenance is crucial to ensure the reliable and safe operation of your car lift.

By carefully considering the factors outlined in this guide, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your automotive needs and workshop requirements.

AAQ for your Car Lift Needs

If you’re in the market for a high-quality car lift, look no further than AAQ.

We offer a wide range of scissor lifts and 2 post car lifts from trusted brands, ensuring you get the perfect solution for your garage or workshop.

At AAQ, you’ll find that Scissor Lifts cost anywhere between $3000 to $12000. Our 2 Post Car Lifts start at around $3000 but cap out at $5000, making them more affordable.

Whether you have very little room to work with or are on a tight budget, browse AAQ’s range today and find the perfect option for your garage.